Store Page

Baked Goods

SWEET home made baked goods from Lancaster County. Indulge yourself in freshly baked items from our Miller's Bakery. Whether you choose Anna Miller's shoofly pie, our world famous chocolate pecan pie, or our delicious raisin bread with icing, you are in for a treat!

GIFT something deliciously different! Our baked goods are great for Easter, Mother's Day, Thanksgiving, Christmas or any other occasion. Each item includes a note that can be personalized with your message.

Product offerings are subject to change.
We only ship within the contiguous United States.

Baked Goods ship on Tuesdays. Orders must be received Monday by 5PM ET in order to ship on Tuesday.

We do not ship Baked Goods the Tuesday before Thanksgiving or the Tuesday after Christmas.

Last day to order Baked Goods for Christmas 2023 is 12/11 at 5PM ET, baked goods will ship on 12/12. This is our last date to ship of 2023. We will resume sending baked goods on 1/9/2024. If you are local, you can place an order for store pick-up at Locally Made Food Shop by calling 717-687-6621 for pick-up of pies or other baked goods anytime prior to Christmas Eve. Please note that for store pick up, we offer a full range of baked goods including sticky buns, honey wheat bread, apple pie and more! Our store is closed Christmas Eve and Christmas Day.

Featured Products